Should nodejs/node#63869 (`--experimental-strip-private-modules`) land? by github-actions[bot] · Pull Request #1900 · nodejs/TSC

github-actions · 2026-10-05T11:33:15Z

Node.js refuses to strip types from TypeScript files under node_modules
and throws ERR_UNSUPPORTED_NODE_MODULES_TYPE_STRIPPING. This keeps
uncompiled TypeScript from becoming the entry point of packages published
to a registry.

nodejs/node#63869 adds
--experimental-strip-private-modules. With the flag, a TypeScript file under
node_modules can be type stripped only if every package enclosing it in the
node_modules chain has "private": true in its root package.json. Nested
package.json files are ignored, and a non-private package anywhere in the
chain (for example, a published package that bundles a private one) refuses
stripping. npm-compatible clients refuse to publish a "private": true
package. The intended use case is workspace packages that are copied rather
than symlinked into node_modules, such as pnpm deploy output, Docker
build contexts and vendored code.
If the first option wins, the request for changes is dismissed and the pull
request lands once it has passed CI. If the second option wins, the pull
request is closed.

Vote instructions:

on the web: https://nodejs.github.io/caritat/#https://github.com/nodejs/TSC/pull/1900

on the CLI:

git node vote https://github.com/nodejs/TSC/pull/1900

To close the vote, at least 3 secret holder(s)¹ must run the following command: git node vote https://github.com/nodejs/TSC/pull/1900 --decrypt-key-part --post-comment

/cc @nodejs/tsc

Current estimated participation: 88.89%

secret holders are folks who have access to the private key associated with a public key on hkps://keys.openpgp.org that references an email address listed on the TSC voting member list at the time of the opening of the vote. ↩

…ivate-modules`) land?"

marco-ippolito · 2026-10-08T15:33:18Z

Ping @ronag @BridgeAR @tniessen @anonrig

This reverts commit 79098bc.

(cherry picked from commit 79098bc)

marco-ippolito · 2026-10-11T11:53:23Z

Ping @anonrig @BridgeAR @RaisinTen

Signed-off-by: Darshan Sen <raisinten@gmail.com>

marco-ippolito · 2026-10-13T19:16:11Z

Last ping @BridgeAR

marco-ippolito · 2026-10-14T06:51:23Z

@nodejs/tsc lets close the vote (I don't have access to a machine so I count on you)

ShogunPanda · 2026-10-14T07:19:10Z

I would like to close this vote, and for this effect, I'm revealing my key part:

-----BEGIN SHAMIR KEY PART-----
xnz8mls9TDfxP+oUhj4CRQk/+rPN4c9Q315AXvZ1LgYR
-----END SHAMIR KEY PART-----

mcollina · 2026-10-15T10:19:05Z

I would like to close this vote, and for this effect, I'm revealing my key part:

-----BEGIN SHAMIR KEY PART-----
RbbOuyYMCnilIYS5v8SlZdp+rCFfVRwTWvVV48rnai0K
-----END SHAMIR KEY PART-----

aduh95 · 2026-10-15T14:01:32Z

I would like to close this vote, and for this effect, I'm revealing my key part:

-----BEGIN SHAMIR KEY PART-----
/vYaGm0F5s6OmmL24oKHumD2QqBDyWXFcIzclWnFjjwB
-----END SHAMIR KEY PART-----

github-actions · 2026-10-15T18:38:08Z

Election results

Subject: Should nodejs/node#63869 (--experimental-strip-private-modules) land?
End date: 2026-10-15T18:38:05.600Z
Participation: 94.44%

Results

Winning candidate: Land nodejs/node#63869: add --experimental-strip-private-modules, which allows type stripping under node_modules only when every enclosing package has "private": true. Extending it to non-private packages stays a documented non-goal

Table of results

Candidate	Number of won duels
Land nodejs/node#63869: add `--experimental-strip-private-modules`, which allows type stripping under `node_modules` only when every enclosing package has `"private": true`. Extending it to non-private packages stays a documented non-goal	1
Do not land nodejs/node#63869: Type stripping files in `node_modules` remains supported only through loaders	0

Voting data

Participants:

Antoine du Hamel <duhamelantoine1995@gmail.com>¹
Benjamin Gruenbaum <benjamingr@gmail.com>²
Chengzhong Wu <legendecas@gmail.com>³
Darshan Sen <raisinten@gmail.com>⁴
Filip Skokan <panva.ip@gmail.com>⁵
Gireesh Punathil <gpunathi@in.ibm.com>⁶
James M Snell <jasnell@gmail.com>⁷
Joyee Cheung <joyeec9h3@gmail.com>⁸
Marco Ippolito <marcoippolito54@gmail.com>⁹
Matteo Collina <matteo.collina@gmail.com>¹⁰
Paolo Insogna <paolo@cowtech.it>¹¹
Rafael Gonzaga <rafael.nunu@hotmail.com>¹²
Richard Lau <richard.lau@ibm.com>¹³
Robert Nagy <ronagy@icloud.com>¹⁴
Ruy Adorno <ruy@vlt.sh>¹⁵
Tobias Nießen <tniessen@tnie.de>¹⁶
Yagiz Nizipli <yagiz@nizipli.com>¹⁷

Private key to decrypt ballots

Discarded commits

Some commits have not been taken into account when counting the ballots:

[
  {
    "commitInfo": {
      "sha": "ef077887915d16e65920097fc65643394980a115",
      "signatureStatus": "E",
      "author": "Antoine du Hamel <duhamelantoine1995@gmail.com>",
      "files": [],
      "deletedFiles": [
        "votes/strip-private-modules/mcollina.json"
      ]
    },
    "reason": "This commit deletes some files."
  },
  {
    "commitInfo": {
      "sha": "8f60e6808c7ffefab1e5389808eee08325326405",
      "signatureStatus": "E",
      "author": "Matteo Collina <matteo.collina@gmail.com>",
      "files": [
        ".editorconfig",
        ".github/dependabot.yml",
        ".github/workflows/ci.yml",
        ".github/workflows/closeVote.yml",
        ".github/workflows/initiateNewVote.yml",
        ".github/workflows/remark-lint-problem-matcher.json",
        ".github/workflows/watchVote.yml",
        ".gitignore",
        ".mailmap",
        ".remarkrc",
        "CODE_OF_CONDUCT.md",
        "Member-Travel-Fund.md",
        "Moderation-Policy.md",
        "Nodejs-Bug-Bounty-Security-Fund.md",
        "Nodejs-Funding-Sources.md",
        "ONBOARDING.md",
        "OpenSSL-Strategy.md",
        "README.md",
        "Strategic-Initiatives.md",
        "Streaming/Streaming-To-Youtube.md",
        "Streaming/youtube-stream-analytics.png",
        "Streaming/youtube-stream-share.png",
        "Streaming/youtube-stream-status.png",
        "Streaming/youtube-stream-title-description.png",
        "TSC-Charter.md",
        "WORKING_GROUPS.md",
        "meetings/2015-05-27.md",
        "meetings/2015-06-03.md",
        "meetings/2015-06-10.md",
        "meetings/2015-06-17.md",
        "meetings/2015-07-01.md",
        "meetings/2015-07-08.md",
        "meetings/2015-07-15.md",
        "meetings/2015-07-22.md",
        "meetings/2015-07-29.md",
        "meetings/2015-08-12.md",
        "meetings/2015-08-19.md",
        "meetings/2015-08-26.md",
        "meetings/2015-09-02.md",
        "meetings/2015-09-16.md",
        "meetings/2015-09-30.md",
        "meetings/2015-10-07.md",
        "meetings/2015-10-14.md",
        "meetings/2015-10-21.md",
        "meetings/2015-12-03.md",
        "meetings/2016-01-07.md",
        "meetings/2016-01-14.md",
        "meetings/2016-01-21.md",
        "meetings/2016-01-28.md",
        "meetings/2016-02-04.md",
        "meetings/2016-02-11.md",
        "meetings/2016-02-18.md",
        "meetings/2016-03-03.md",
        "meetings/2016-03-10.md",
        "meetings/2016-03-17.md",
        "meetings/2016-03-24.md",
        "meetings/2016-04-07.md",
        "meetings/2016-04-21.md",
        "meetings/2016-05-05.md",
        "meetings/2016-05-19.md",
        "meetings/2016-06-16.md",
        "meetings/2016-06-30.md",
        "meetings/2016-07-14.md",
        "meetings/2016-08-04.md",
        "meetings/2016-08-11.md",
        "meetings/2016-08-25.md",
        "meetings/2016-09-08.md",
        "meetings/2016-09-22.md",
        "meetings/2016-10-06.md",
        "meetings/2016-10-20.md",
        "meetings/2016-11-03.md",
        "meetings/2016-11-17.md",
        "meetings/2016-12-15.md",
        "meetings/2017-01-12.md",
        "meetings/2017-01-26.md",
        "meetings/2017-02-09.md",
        "meetings/2017-02-23.md",
        "meetings/2017-03-09.md",
        "meetings/2017-03-23.md",
        "meetings/2017-04-06.md",
        "meetings/2017-06-01.md",
        "meetings/2017-06-29.md",
        "meetings/2017-09-13.md",
        "meetings/2017-09-20.md",
        "meetings/2017-09-27.md",
        "meetings/2017-10-11.md",
        "meetings/2017-10-18.md",
        "meetings/2017-10-25.md",
        "meetings/2017-11-01.md",
        "meetings/2017-11-08.md",
        "meetings/2017-11-15.md",
        "meetings/2017-11-22.md",
        "meetings/2017-11-29.md",
        "meetings/2017-12-06.md",
        "meetings/2017-12-13.md",
        "meetings/2017-12-20.md",
        "meetings/2018-01-10.md",
        "meetings/2018-01-17.md",
        "meetings/2018-01-31-V8.md",
        "meetings/2018-01-31.md",
        "meetings/2018-02-07.md",
        "meetings/2018-02-21.md",
        "meetings/2018-02-28.md",
        "meetings/2018-03-07.md",
        "meetings/2018-03-14.md",
        "meetings/2018-03-21.md",
        "meetings/2018-03-28.md",
        "meetings/2018-04-04.md",
        "meetings/2018-04-11.md",
        "meetings/2018-04-18.md",
        "meetings/2018-04-25.md",
        "meetings/2018-05-02.md",
        "meetings/2018-05-09.md",
        "meetings/2018-05-16.md",
        "meetings/2018-05-23.md",
        "meetings/2018-06-06.md",
        "meetings/2018-06-13.md",
        "meetings/2018-06-20.md",
        "meetings/2018-06-27.md",
        "meetings/2018-07-12.md",
        "meetings/2018-07-18.md",
        "meetings/2018-08-01.md",
        "meetings/2018-08-08.md",
        "meetings/2018-08-22.md",
        "meetings/2018-08-29.md",
        "meetings/2018-09-05.md",
        "meetings/2018-09-12.md",
        "meetings/2018-09-19.md",
        "meetings/2018-09-26.md",
        "meetings/2018-10-03.md",
        "meetings/2018-10-17.md",
        "meetings/2018-10-24.md",
        "meetings/2018-10-31.md",
        "meetings/2018-11-07.md",
        "meetings/2018-11-14.md",
        "meetings/2018-12-05.md",
        "meetings/2018-12-12.md",
        "meetings/2018-12-19.md",
        "meetings/2019-01-02.md",
        "meetings/2019-01-16.md",
        "meetings/2019-01-23.md",
        "meetings/2019-01-30.md",
        "meetings/2019-02-14.md",
        "meetings/2019-02-20.md",
        "meetings/2019-03-14.md",
        "meetings/2019-03-27.md",
        "meetings/2019-04-10.md",
        "meetings/2019-04-17.md",
        "meetings/2019-04-24.md",
        "meetings/2019-05-15.md",
        "meetings/2019-06-05.md",
        "meetings/2019-06-19.md",
        "meetings/2019-06-26.md",
        "meetings/2019-07-03.md",
        "meetings/2019-07-10.md",
        "meetings/2019-07-24.md",
        "meetings/2019-07-29.md",
        "meetings/2019-08-07.md",
        "meetings/2019-08-14.md",
        "meetings/2019-08-21.md",
        "meetings/2019-08-28.md",
        "meetings/2019-09-11.md",
        "meetings/2019-09-18.md",
        "meetings/2019-09-25.md",
        "meetings/2019-10-16.md",
        "meetings/2019-10-23.md",
        "meetings/2019-11-06.md",
        "meetings/2019-11-20.md",
        "meetings/2019-11-27.md",
        "meetings/2019-12-04.md",
        "meetings/2020-01-08.md",
        "meetings/2020-01-15.md",
        "meetings/2020-01-22.md",
        "meetings/2020-02-05.md",
        "meetings/2020-02-19.md",
        "meetings/2020-02-26.md",
        "meetings/2020-03-11.md",
        "meetings/2020-03-18.md",
        "meetings/2020-04-01.md",
        "meetings/2020-04-08.md",
        "meetings/2020-04-16.md",
        "meetings/2020-04-23.md",
        "meetings/2020-04-29.md",
        "meetings/2020-05-07.md",
        "meetings/2020-05-14.md",
        "meetings/2020-05-21.md",
        "meetings/2020-06-04.md",
        "meetings/2020-07-02.md",
        "meetings/2020-07-09.md",
        "meetings/2020-07-16.md",
        "meetings/2020-08-06.md",
        "meetings/2020-08-13.md",
        "meetings/2020-08-27.md",
        "meetings/2020-09-03.md",
        "meetings/2020-09-16.md",
        "meetings/2020-09-24.md",
        "meetings/2020-10-01.md",
        "meetings/2020-10-08.md",
        "meetings/2020-10-29.md",
        "meetings/2020-11-11.md",
        "meetings/2020-12-09.md",
        "meetings/2021-01-14.md",
        "meetings/2021-02-04.md",
        "meetings/2021-02-25.md",
        "meetings/2021-03-18.md",
        "meetings/2021-03-25.md",
        "meetings/2021-04-08.md",
        "meetings/2021-04-15.md",
        "meetings/2021-04-22.md",
        "meetings/2021-04-29.md",
        "meetings/2021-05-20.md",
        "meetings/2021-06-10.md",
        "meetings/2021-06-23.md",
        "meetings/2021-07-01.md",
        "meetings/2021-07-14.md",
        "meetings/2021-07-22.md",
        "meetings/2021-07-29.md",
        "meetings/2021-08-04.md",
        "meetings/2021-08-25.md",
        "meetings/2021-09-23.md",
        "meetings/2021-09-30.md",
        "meetings/2021-10-06.md",
        "meetings/2021-10-14.md",
        "meetings/2021-10-21.md",
        "meetings/2021-10-27.md",
        "meetings/2021-11-04.md",
        "meetings/2021-11-17.md",
        "meetings/2021-12-02.md",
        "meetings/2021-12-08.md",
        "meetings/2021-12-16.md",
        "meetings/2022-01-06.md",
        "meetings/2022-01-13.md",
        "meetings/2022-01-19.md",
        "meetings/2022-01-26.md",
        "meetings/2022-02-03.md",
        "meetings/2022-02-10.md",
        "meetings/2022-02-16.md",
        "meetings/2022-02-23.md",
        "meetings/2022-03-03.md",
        "meetings/2022-03-10.md",
        "meetings/2022-03-23.md",
        "meetings/2022-03-31.md",
        "meetings/2022-04-06.md",
        "meetings/2022-04-13.md",
        "meetings/2022-04-20.md",
        "meetings/2022-04-27.md",
        "meetings/2022-05-04.md",
        "meetings/2022-05-11.md",
        "meetings/2022-05-18.md",
        "meetings/2022-05-25.md",
        "meetings/2022-06-01.md",
        "meetings/2022-06-15.md",
        "meetings/2022-06-22.md",
        "meetings/2022-06-29.md",
        "meetings/2022-07-06.md",
        "meetings/2022-07-13.md",
        "meetings/2022-07-20.md",
        "meetings/2022-07-27.md",
        "meetings/2022-08-03.md",
        "meetings/2022-08-10.md",
        "meetings/2022-09-07.md",
        "meetings/2022-09-21.md",
        "meetings/2022-09-28.md",
        "meetings/2022-10-12.md",
        "meetings/2022-10-19.md",
        "meetings/2022-11-02.md",
        "meetings/2022-11-09.md",
        "meetings/2022-11-23.md",
        "meetings/2022-11-30.md",
        "meetings/2022-12-07.md",
        "meetings/2022-12-14.md",
        "meetings/2022-12-21.md",
        "meetings/2023-01-04.md",
        "meetings/2023-01-11.md",
        "meetings/2023-01-18.md",
        "meetings/2023-01-25.md",
        "meetings/2023-02-01.md",
        "meetings/2023-02-15.md",
        "meetings/2023-02-22.md",
        "meetings/2023-03-08.md",
        "meetings/2023-03-15.md",
        "meetings/2023-03-22.md",
        "meetings/2023-03-29.md",
        "meetings/2023-04-12.md",
        "meetings/2023-04-19.md",
        "meetings/2023-05-03.md",
        "meetings/2023-05-17.md",
        "meetings/2023-05-24.md",
        "meetings/2023-05-31.md",
        "meetings/2023-06-07.md",
        "meetings/2023-06-14.md",
        "meetings/2023-06-21.md",
        "meetings/2023-07-05.md",
        "meetings/2023-07-12.md",
        "meetings/2023-07-19.md",
        "meetings/2023-07-26.md",
        "meetings/2023-08-02.md",
        "meetings/2023-08-23.md",
        "meetings/2023-08-30.md",
        "meetings/2023-09-06.md",
        "meetings/2023-09-13.md",
        "meetings/2023-09-20.md",
        "meetings/2023-09-27.md",
        "meetings/2023-10-04.md",
        "meetings/2023-10-11.md",
        "meetings/2023-10-18.md",
        "meetings/2023-10-25.md",
        "meetings/2023-11-08.md",
        "meetings/2023-11-15.md",
        "meetings/2023-11-22.md",
        "meetings/2023-11-29.md",
        "meetings/2023-12-06.md",
        "meetings/2023-12-20.md",
        "meetings/2024-01-03.md",
        "meetings/2024-01-10.md",
        "meetings/2024-01-17.md",
        "meetings/2024-01-24.md",
        "meetings/2024-01-31.md",
        "meetings/2024-02-07.md",
        "meetings/2024-02-21.md",
        "meetings/2024-02-28.md",
        "meetings/2024-03-06.md",
        "meetings/2024-03-13.md",
        "meetings/2024-03-20.md",
        "meetings/2024-03-27.md",
        "meetings/2024-04-10.md",
        "meetings/2024-04-17.md",
        "meetings/2024-04-24.md",
        "meetings/2024-05-08.md",
        "meetings/2024-05-15.md",
        "meetings/2024-05-22.md",
        "meetings/2024-05-29.md",
        "meetings/2024-06-05.md",
        "meetings/2024-06-19.md",
        "meetings/2024-06-26.md",
        "meetings/2024-07-03.md",
        "meetings/2024-07-10.md",
        "meetings/2024-07-17.md",
        "meetings/2024-07-24.md",
        "meetings/2024-07-31.md",
        "meetings/2024-08-14.md",
        "meetings/2024-08-21.md",
        "meetings/2024-09-04.md",
        "meetings/2024-09-11.md",
        "meetings/2024-09-18.md",
        "meetings/2024-10-02.md",
        "meetings/2024-10-16.md",
        "meetings/2024-10-23.md",
        "meetings/2024-10-30.md",
        "meetings/2024-11-13.md",
        "meetings/2024-11-20.md",
        "meetings/2024-12-04.md",
        "meetings/2024-12-11.md",
        "meetings/2024-12-18.md",
        "meetings/2025-01-08.md",
        "meetings/2025-01-22.md",
        "meetings/2025-01-29.md",
        "meetings/2025-02-05.md",
        "meetings/2025-02-12.md",
        "meetings/2025-03-05.md",
        "meetings/2025-03-19.md",
        "meetings/2025-04-09.md",
        "meetings/2025-04-16.md",
        "meetings/2025-04-23.md",
        "meetings/2025-04-30.md",
        "meetings/2025-05-07.md",
        "meetings/2025-05-28.md",
        "meetings/2025-06-11.md",
        "meetings/2025-06-18.md",
        "meetings/2025-06-25.md",
        "meetings/2025-07-02.md",
        "meetings/2025-07-16.md",
        "meetings/2025-07-23.md",
        "meetings/2025-07-30.md",
        "meetings/2025-08-06.md",
        "meetings/2025-10-15.md",
        "meetings/2026-01-07.md",
        "meetings/2026-01-28.md",
        "meetings/2026-02-11.md",
        "meetings/2026-02-18.md",
        "meetings/2026-03-04.md",
        "meetings/2026-03-18.md",
        "meetings/2026-03-25.md",
        "meetings/2026-04-01.md",
        "meetings/2026-05-06.md",
        "meetings/gen-meeting.sh",
        "meetings/io.js/2014-10-09.md",
        "meetings/io.js/2014-10-15.md",
        "meetings/io.js/2014-10-29.md",
        "meetings/io.js/2014-12-10.md",
        "meetings/io.js/2014-12-17.md",
        "meetings/io.js/2014-12-30.md",
        "meetings/io.js/2015-01-07.md",
        "meetings/io.js/2015-01-13.md",
        "meetings/io.js/2015-01-21.md",
        "meetings/io.js/2015-01-28.md",
        "meetings/io.js/2015-02-04.md",
        "meetings/io.js/2015-02-18.md",
        "meetings/io.js/2015-03-04.md",
        "meetings/io.js/2015-03-18.md",
        "meetings/io.js/2015-04-01.md",
        "meetings/io.js/2015-04-08.md",
        "meetings/io.js/2015-04-15.md",
        "meetings/io.js/2015-04-22.md",
        "meetings/io.js/2015-04-29.md",
        "meetings/io.js/2015-05-13.md",
        "meetings/node.js/2014-12-10.md",
        "meetings/node.js/2014-12-16.md",
        "meetings/node.js/2014-12-18.md",
        "meetings/node.js/2015-01-15.md",
        "meetings/node.js/2015-01-22.md",
        "meetings/node.js/2015-01-29.md",
        "meetings/node.js/2015-02-05.md",
        "meetings/node.js/2015-02-09.md",
        "meetings/node.js/2015-02-19.md",
        "meetings/node.js/2015-02-26.md",
        "meetings/node.js/2015-03-05.md",
        "meetings/node.js/2015-03-12.md",
        "meetings/node.js/2015-03-19.md",
        "meetings/node.js/2015-03-26.md",
        "meetings/node.js/2015-04-09.md",
        "meetings/node.js/2015-04-16.md",
        "meetings/node.js/2015-04-24.md",
        "meetings/node.js/2015-04-30.md",
        "meetings/node.js/2015-05-07.md",
        "meetings/node.js/2015-05-21.md",
        "meetings/node.js/2015-06-04.md",
        "package-lock.json",
        "package.json",
        "surveys/2020 Node.js Contributors Survey Results.pdf",
        "surveys/promise-rejections/raw-data.xlsx",
        "surveys/promise-rejections/survey.md",
        "votes/2021-09-29-0.json",
        "votes/2021-10-19-0.json",
        "votes/2022-01-10-0.json",
        "votes/2022-02-21-0.json",
        "votes/2022-04-11-0.json",
        "votes/2022-04-11-1.json",
        "votes/2022-05-11-0.json",
        "votes/2022-05-18-0.json",
        "votes/2022-07-06-0.json",
        "votes/2022-07-20-0.json",
        "votes/2022-08-31-0.json",
        "votes/2022-08-31-1.json",
        "votes/2022-09-15-0.json",
        "votes/2022-11-30-0.json",
        "votes/2022-11-30-1.json",
        "votes/2023-03-26-0.json",
        "votes/2024-05-07-0.json",
        "votes/2024-06-25-0.json",
        "votes/2024-09-30-0.json",
        "votes/2025-03-19-0.json",
        "votes/2025-08-01-0.json",
        "votes/README.md",
        "votes/initiateNewVote/README.md",
        "votes/initiateNewVote/_EDIT_ME.yml",
        "votes/initiateNewVote/_generateNewVotePR.mjs",
        "votes/initiateNewVote/decryptPrivateKeyAndCloseVote.mjs",
        "votes/initiateNewVote/extractInfoFromReadme.mjs",
        "votes/initiateNewVote/generateNewVote.mjs",
        "votes/initiateNewVote/generateNewVotePR.mjs",
        "votes/initiateNewVote/getVoteStatus.mjs"
      ],
      "deletedFiles": []
    },
    "reason": "This commit touches more than one file."
  },
  {
    "commitInfo": {
      "sha": "79098bcd7f659e960424b357ad22f88f08a34848",
      "signatureStatus": "E",
      "author": "Matteo Collina <matteo.collina@gmail.com>",
      "files": [
        "votes/strip-private-modules/mcollina.json"
      ],
      "deletedFiles": []
    },
    "reason": "A more recent vote commit from this author has already been counted."
  }
]

Voted for Do not land module: add --experimental-strip-private-modules node#63869: Type stripping files in node_modules remains supported only through loaders. ↩
Voted for Land module: add --experimental-strip-private-modules node#63869: add --experimental-strip-private-modules, which allows type stripping under node_modules only when every enclosing package has "private": true. Extending it to non-private packages stays a documented non-goal. ↩
Voted for Land module: add --experimental-strip-private-modules node#63869: add --experimental-strip-private-modules, which allows type stripping under node_modules only when every enclosing package has "private": true. Extending it to non-private packages stays a documented non-goal. ↩
Voted for Land module: add --experimental-strip-private-modules node#63869: add --experimental-strip-private-modules, which allows type stripping under node_modules only when every enclosing package has "private": true. Extending it to non-private packages stays a documented non-goal. ↩
Voted for Land module: add --experimental-strip-private-modules node#63869: add --experimental-strip-private-modules, which allows type stripping under node_modules only when every enclosing package has "private": true. Extending it to non-private packages stays a documented non-goal. ↩
Voted for Land module: add --experimental-strip-private-modules node#63869: add --experimental-strip-private-modules, which allows type stripping under node_modules only when every enclosing package has "private": true. Extending it to non-private packages stays a documented non-goal. ↩
Voted for Land module: add --experimental-strip-private-modules node#63869: add --experimental-strip-private-modules, which allows type stripping under node_modules only when every enclosing package has "private": true. Extending it to non-private packages stays a documented non-goal. ↩
Voted for Land module: add --experimental-strip-private-modules node#63869: add --experimental-strip-private-modules, which allows type stripping under node_modules only when every enclosing package has "private": true. Extending it to non-private packages stays a documented non-goal. ↩
Voted for Land module: add --experimental-strip-private-modules node#63869: add --experimental-strip-private-modules, which allows type stripping under node_modules only when every enclosing package has "private": true. Extending it to non-private packages stays a documented non-goal. ↩
Voted for Land module: add --experimental-strip-private-modules node#63869: add --experimental-strip-private-modules, which allows type stripping under node_modules only when every enclosing package has "private": true. Extending it to non-private packages stays a documented non-goal. ↩
Voted for Land module: add --experimental-strip-private-modules node#63869: add --experimental-strip-private-modules, which allows type stripping under node_modules only when every enclosing package has "private": true. Extending it to non-private packages stays a documented non-goal. ↩
Abstained. ↩
Voted for Land module: add --experimental-strip-private-modules node#63869: add --experimental-strip-private-modules, which allows type stripping under node_modules only when every enclosing package has "private": true. Extending it to non-private packages stays a documented non-goal. ↩
Voted for Land module: add --experimental-strip-private-modules node#63869: add --experimental-strip-private-modules, which allows type stripping under node_modules only when every enclosing package has "private": true. Extending it to non-private packages stays a documented non-goal. ↩
Abstained. ↩
Voted for Land module: add --experimental-strip-private-modules node#63869: add --experimental-strip-private-modules, which allows type stripping under node_modules only when every enclosing package has "private": true. Extending it to non-private packages stays a documented non-goal. ↩
Voted for Land module: add --experimental-strip-private-modules node#63869: add --experimental-strip-private-modules, which allows type stripping under node_modules only when every enclosing package has "private": true. Extending it to non-private packages stays a documented non-goal. ↩

github-actions Bot and others added 11 commits October 5, 2026 11:33

Initiate vote for "Should nodejs/node#63869 (`--experimental-strip-pr…

9fd3b50

…ivate-modules`) land?"

vote from panva

24d90a6

vote from marco-ippolito

5171d8a

vote from joyeecheung

9d9f80c

vote from aduh95

8d7475d

Add jasnell.json with encrypted data

0f734c7

vote from gireeshpunathil

12f659e

vote from ShogunPanda

6dc6f68

vote from richardlau

580e04a

vote from benjamingr

98ecc44

vote from RafaelGSS

c0d006a

mcollina mentioned this pull request Oct 7, 2026

Node.js Technical Steering Committee (TSC) Meeting 2026-10-07 #1898

Closed

vote from mcollina

79098bc

This comment was marked as resolved.

Sign in to view

ruyadorno and others added 2 commits October 7, 2026 17:44

vote from ruyadorno

7fcbae3

Add legendecas.json

6baeb38

aduh95 and others added 3 commits October 8, 2026 18:07

Revert "vote from mcollina"

ef07788

This reverts commit 79098bc.

Merge branch 'main'

3141bd9

vote from mcollina

8165c0a

(cherry picked from commit 79098bc)

This comment was marked as off-topic.

Sign in to view

tniessen and others added 2 commits October 9, 2026 15:58

Add vote for tniessen

d95889c

Create ronag

d90084c

RaisinTen and others added 2 commits October 11, 2026 17:44

vote from RaisinTen

7c81014

Signed-off-by: Darshan Sen <raisinten@gmail.com>

Add anonrig configuration with encrypted secrets

6565bc4

close vote and aggregate results

90d4ea4

fixup! close vote and aggregate results

8613a1d

Navigation Menu

Repository navigation

Should nodejs/node#63869 (`--experimental-strip-private-modules`) land? - #1900

Should nodejs/node#63869 (`--experimental-strip-private-modules`) land?#1900
github-actions[bot] wants to merge 23 commits into
mainfrom
votes/strip-private-modules

github-actions Bot commented Oct 5, 2026 •

edited

Loading

Uh oh!

This comment was marked as resolved.

marco-ippolito commented Oct 8, 2026

Uh oh!

This comment was marked as off-topic.

marco-ippolito commented Oct 11, 2026 •

edited

Loading

Uh oh!

marco-ippolito commented Oct 13, 2026

Uh oh!

marco-ippolito commented Oct 14, 2026 •

edited

Loading

Uh oh!

ShogunPanda commented Oct 14, 2026 •

edited by aduh95

Loading

Uh oh!

mcollina commented Oct 15, 2026

Uh oh!

aduh95 commented Oct 15, 2026

Uh oh!

github-actions Bot commented Oct 15, 2026

Uh oh!

Reviewers

Assignees

Labels

Projects

Milestone

Development

Uh oh!

17 participants

Conversation

github-actions Bot commented Oct 5, 2026 • edited Loading Uh oh! There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.

Uh oh!

Footnotes

Uh oh!

This comment was marked as resolved.

marco-ippolito commented Oct 8, 2026

Uh oh!

This comment was marked as off-topic.

marco-ippolito commented Oct 11, 2026 • edited Loading Uh oh! There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

marco-ippolito commented Oct 13, 2026

Uh oh!

marco-ippolito commented Oct 14, 2026 • edited Loading Uh oh! There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

ShogunPanda commented Oct 14, 2026 • edited by aduh95 Loading Uh oh! There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

mcollina commented Oct 15, 2026

Uh oh!

aduh95 commented Oct 15, 2026

Uh oh!

github-actions Bot commented Oct 15, 2026

Election results

Results

Table of results

Voting data

Footnotes

Uh oh!

Reviewers

Assignees

Labels

Projects

Milestone

Development

Uh oh!

17 participants

github-actions Bot commented Oct 5, 2026 •

edited

Loading

marco-ippolito commented Oct 11, 2026 •

edited

Loading

marco-ippolito commented Oct 14, 2026 •

edited

Loading

ShogunPanda commented Oct 14, 2026 •

edited by aduh95

Loading